Should pregnancy home doppler devices be available for over the counter sale?

To Ban or not to ban?

The current campaign by leading baby charity ‘Kicks Count’ has sparked debate. The charity has called for a ban on over the counter sales of hand held dopplers. Personally and professionally I can see both sides of the argument but here I’ll tell you why I’m supporting them.

Kicks Count
Kicks Count

So first, what is a home doppler for pregnancy?

It’s a small hand held device that allows you to hear your baby’s heartbeat whilst at home. It works in the same way as the hand held dopplers the Health Care Professionals (HCP’s) use. However hand held dopplers cannot interpret the readings for you in the same way a HCP would. There are also apps on phones that allow you to listen too. On the surface this may seem like a lovely idea, provide some reassurance at home and allow partners to hear your unborn baby’s heart beating. Some say it helps with the bonding process too.

But are they really suitable for home use by someone who isn’t trained to use them?

Firstly, locating the heartbeat requires skill and it needs to be distinguished from other sounds picked up by the device. The sound made by the placenta can sometimes sound like a heartbeat.

Secondly and most importantly, the mere presence of a heartbeat does not always mean the baby is ok. Sadly no heartbeat is too late. Our concern is that a mum worried about her baby’s movements may listen to her baby’s heartbeat at home and be reassured by the presence of a heartbeat. Thus, not going into hospital for a review which may have detected a distressed baby prompting imminent delivery and saving a life.

Midwives and doctors train to use these devices. Listening to a baby’s heartbeat needs to be understood along with the physiology of pregnancy and the anatomy of the heart. Training includes being able to listen to the pattern and rate of the heartbeat and interpret those sounds in order to determine the wellbeing of the baby.

Now I know that for some, these devices and apps provide comforting reassurance through an anxious pregnancy. I also completely understand that it is lovely to hear your baby’s heartbeat. But these devices and apps may provide a false reassurance.

So what is the answer?

Ban the over counter sale of them or increase education on the sensible use of home dopplers. Education is a valid choice but this in itself poses problems. How long will such education take to reach all pregnant mums and how many times will a mother be falsely reassured whilst a programme of education is developed and rolled out? When should it be discussed? Despite education will people still use them for reassurance when worried? Of course there are plenty of sensible women out there that would use one purely for bonding and would go for monitoring if concerned. Is it right to take away that choice? But there are those that will still use one for reassurance. Maybe a fear of hospitals will lead them to using a home doppler. Maybe they don’t want to ‘bother’ maternity staff or convince themselves that they are worrying over nothing.

Educational messages take time, we are still trying to dispel myths regarding fetal movements towards the end of pregnancy. There are 6500 stillbirths and neonatal deaths every year in the UK and we must do what we can to get this number down. Education may sound like the best option but it takes time to get these important messages out there and save lives.

Banning them for over the counter sale may sound drastic and taking away choice but it may save the lives of many unborn babies sooner. It is after all a medical device.

Please, if you are worried about a change in your baby’s movements, call your maternity unit straight away. Remember a baby’s movements do not slow down towards the end of pregnancy. You are not a bother. Let the HCP’s reassure you, not a device or app you use at home.

 

What are your thoughts? Should they be banned for over the counter sale? If you support the campaign please read what Elizabeth Hutton, CEO of Kicks Count has to say and sign the petition. Visit Kicks Counts here.

 

Mudpie Fridays
Bridie By The Sea
Naptime Natter

12 COMMENTS

  1. I didn’t even know these existed. I would leave it to the professionals and it would be heartbreaking to think you’ve made a decision on DIY tests, only to find medical intervention needed to be taken earlier. #BloggersClubUK

  2. I agree completely. So many women I know have told me they’ve listened to their babies heartbeat at home, then described it as a whooshing sound, which to me sounds more like placenta. That concerns me hugely. I think having them about can increase worrying no end – I feel the same about video baby monitors. There’s always the ‘risk’ that you end up glued to it and unable to switch off. Brill post #DreamTeam

  3. I have never been comfortable with people using these, for all the reasons you mention. I actually stopped using sites like Babycentre as they were full of women claiming to have heard the fetal heart at ten weeks with their doppler…and I didn’t want to get into arguments about the use of them! A ban is the only way forward. Safety of the baby should be the most important thing. If people want to hear their baby’s heartbeat at home, they should ask their midwife if they can record it at an appointment.
    #BloggerClubUK

  4. really interesting post, i have had midwife apts when they struggled to find the heartbeat and it scared me. These must lead to some very scary times for parents to be and a huge amount of worry. As you said any concerns speak to your midwife and let them check and makesure your ok. Great post #Blogstravaganza

  5. This is the first I’ve heard of then being available. I can see how it would be comforting to be able to hear your baby’s heartbeat at home, but personally I wouldn’t feel qualified to use one and I’m not sure how reassuring I would find it as I wouldn’t know whether the heartbeat sounded healthy or in distress. I would probably make myself ill listening to it obsessively and trying to analyse small changes. Personally I think that these things are better in the hands of those that have trained and are qualified to use them. #blogcrush x

  6. This is so interesting to read and I have to agree – I didn’t get a home Doppler system simply because I wouldn’t know how to use it properly. My baby was really lazy, but I preferred to go in and make sure she was ok than to try and work it out myself! #blogstravaganza

  7. I think hearing your baby’s heartbeat is a great experience. My first pregnancy was in difficult circumstances and I found it hard to bond with my bump, even after seeing the baby at the scan. But it was hearing that heartbeat that finally moved me and helped me to start bonding and looking forward to the birth.

    However, I didn’t have a home doppler device, and I can really understand from reading this post why there is a call to have them banned. I think I would definitely have used it as a reassurance thing and, as you say, that is not really what it is for. Once more, a really informative article about real, important issues. Love your site! #blogcrush

  8. I’m with you, I think if there are any concerns women are best to see their doctor. If I had one of these I’d be obsessively checking then freaking out if I couldn’t find a heartbeat so definitely not for me! Thank you for sharing with us at #BloggerClubUK xx

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here